PROJECT 1776

The footprint of Hispanic Scholasticism in the US Declaration of Independence.

Research project in development on the occasion of the 250th anniversary of the Declaration of Independence of the United States of America (1776–2026).

Agreement with Instituto de Fe y Libertad

Escuela Hispánica has begun working jointly with the Instituto Fe y Libertad on various initiatives aimed at the research and dissemination of Hispanic thought on liberty. In this context, we would like to announce the open call for submissions to the Institute's academic journal, whose next edition will be dedicated to topics related to Project 1776 and the influence of the Hispanic tradition on the development of modern political thought.

The initiative seeks to continue expanding the study of the Hispanic tradition and its influence on the development of modern political thought, while promoting new spaces for academic dialogue and international intellectual cooperation. We invite all those interested in contributing articles or research related to this topic to contact the Instituto Fe y Libertad for more information on the publication process.

Introduction

From Escuela Hispánica we have promoted Project 1776; an ongoing research project marking the 250th anniversary of the Declaration of Independence of the United States of America (1776–2026). This project explores the influence of the political thought of the Second Scholasticism—especially the School of Salamanca—on the intellectual origins of American constitutionalism and the defense of individual freedom against absolute power.
Various authors have shown that many of the principles we today consider pillars of modern democracies and, in particular, of the American republic—such as human dignity, popular sovereignty, the limitation of power, or respect for individual conscience—were formulated centuries earlier by Catholic theologians and jurists of the 16th and 17th centuries. A key example is the famous formula of the Jesuit Francisco Suárez (1548–1617): “Omnis potestas a Deo, populum consentientem” (“All power comes from God, but through the consent of the people”). This conception of political power as delegated by the community—and not as an absolute authority granted directly to the monarch—dismantles the cliché that modern Catholic thought supported absolutism. In fact, it was often Protestant reformers, both Lutheran and Anglican, who sustained monarchical models “by the grace of God”.
The leading exponents of the School of Salamanca, influenced by Thomas Aquinas and headed by figures such as Francisco de Vitoria, Juan de Mariana, Robert Bellarmine, and Suárez himself, developed a theological-juridical vision of the political order based on natural law, moral law, and rationality. These ideas spread through universities, seminaries, and libraries, both in the Iberian Peninsula and in Hispanic America, constituting what we might today call an authentic “Hispanic tradition of liberty”.
Traditionally, academic studies have focused on the impact of this tradition during the Hispanic American independence processes (1810–2010). Researchers such as Carlos Stoetzer, Fr. Furlong, or institutes and research centers like the Fe y Libertad Institute (Guatemala) have demonstrated how the scholastics influenced the emerging republican doctrines in Hispanic America, especially through the Jesuit educational network.
However, Project 1776 broadens this horizon to also analyze its possible influence on the independence of the United States. Although the Anglo-Saxon world did not have a scholastic institutional infrastructure as developed as in Hispanic America, there are growing indications of the circulation and reception of authors from the Hispanic tradition—especially Suárez and Bellarmine—in the British colonies. This is suggested by works such as those of Rafael Termes, recent research on George Mason, and reflections like those of Professor Karl Maurer, who noted:

“It is undeniable that Thomas Jefferson, author of the Declaration of Independence, and George Mason, author of the Virginia Declaration of Rights, were well acquainted with the great classical and contemporary thinkers since Aristotle. And it is not unreasonable to conclude that they were also familiar with writers who defended popular sovereignty and opposed the absolute power of kings.”

Source: Catholic Culture
A decade ago, the president of Escuela Hispánica, Alejandro Chafuen, proposed this line of research in an article published in Forbes: “Hispanics Finding Roots and Helping Build Our America”. More recently, José Sáenz Crespo took up this issue in an interview for the Intercollegiate Studies Institute with Juan A. Soto and Enrique Pallares, where the need to rediscover a “Hispanic tradition of liberty”, unjustly forgotten in Anglo-Saxon narratives, is defended.
Thus, the objective of this project is not only to recover an intellectual genealogy alternative to the Enlightenment-Protestant narrative of the origins of the United States, but also to show how Catholic political philosophy—when based on the dignity of the person, natural law, and moral freedom—can contribute to the universal ideals of justice and limited government.
Just as in recent decades the historical role of Spain in military terms in the independence of the United States has been vindicated—let us remember that it was Bernardo de Gálvez, and not Lafayette, who marched alongside George Washington in the victory parade—it is now time to also investigate the intellectual plane: the relationship between the political traditions that contributed to the philosophical pillars of those incipient united states of North America.
The Hispanic tradition should not, therefore, be understood as an antagonist to the Anglo-American one, but as complementary and necessary to sustain the enormous weight of the Western project. It is a vast, rich, and chronologically earlier tradition, whose impact is increasingly evident both indirectly—through the Scottish Enlightenment—and directly on the Founding Fathers of the United States themselves. The West is not the exclusive product of a single intellectual current, but the sum of the Hispanic tradition, the Anglo-American one, and a constellation of minor continental European traditions; all of them necessary to support its moral, juridical, and political architecture. In this sense, Project 1776 aspires to vindicate the indispensable role of the Hispanic tradition, its deep connection with the Anglo-American one, and its responsibility in the intellectual and philosophical support of the West, frequently minimized over the last two centuries.
This is, therefore, a history to be rediscovered, on the 250th anniversary of the Declaration of Independence and beyond.
Project 1776 seeks not only to recover a forgotten intellectual genealogy, but also to offer an alternative vision—Hispanic, humanist, and Catholic—of the birth of modern constitutionalism.

"THE MARCH OF GÁLVEZ" - AUGUSTO FERRER-DALMAU

This painting represents General Bernardo de Gálvez leading his troops through a swamp during the American Revolutionary War campaign. Carrying both a Spanish and an American flag, Gálvez on horseback guides his men as they advance with difficulty through water and vegetation. Soldiers of different races, including Native Americans, participate in the march, reflecting the diversity and determination of the army fighting for freedom.

Milestones of Thought

1550–1600

Iberian university network and the birth of modern economics

Read moreRead less
In the universities of Salamanca, Alcalá, Valladolid, Coimbra, and Évora, a systematic reflection on economics, law, and politics develops in the context of Atlantic expansion. This academic network explores fundamental theological and philosophical concepts—such as human dignity, social sovereignty, or natural rights—and describes the market as a spontaneous order arising from free human interaction. Their analyses of property, value, exchange, and currency will contribute to the birth of economic science itself. This intellectual affiliation was later recognized by the Austrian School of Economics: Joseph Schumpeter, in History of Economic Analysis (1954), described the scholastic doctors as founders of scientific economics; Friedrich Hayek, in Law, Legislation and Liberty (1973-1979) and Studies in Philosophy, Politics and Economics (1967), pointed out that they anticipated the theory of the spontaneous order of the market; and Murray Rothbard, in Economic Thought Before Adam Smith (1995), presented them as direct precursors of modern economic liberalism.

1539

Francisco de Vitoria: Relectio de Indis

Read moreRead less
Vitoria affirms the natural equality of all men and formulates the law of nations, the basis of modern international law. He denies the legitimacy of dominion based solely on force and establishes universal principles of justice among peoples. These ideas would be developed later by the Second Scholasticism—especially by Juan de Mariana—and would pass to the Protestant world through authors like Hugo Grotius, who systemized modern international law in the 17th century taking the juridical-moral thought born in the Iberian universities as a reference.

1553–1569

Domingo de Soto: just price and the market

Read moreRead less
In De Iustitia et Iure (1553–1554), De Soto argues that the just price is not fixed by authority but by the market, as a result of the common estimation of buyers and sellers. With this he legitimizes competitive commerce and limits political intervention in the economy. This notion anticipates the theory of spontaneous price formation that Adam Smith would systemize centuries later in classical economics, integrating it into his explanation of the economic order based on the free interaction of individuals.

1556

Martín de Azpilcueta: quantity theory of money

Read moreRead less
In his Comentario resolutorio de cambios, Azpilcueta observes that the abundance of metals from the Americas causes inflation and formulates an early quantity theory of money: the value of currency depends on its relative scarcity. This explanation of purchasing power anticipates modern monetary theory and will reach European political economy, indirectly influencing the monetary debates of the Anglo-Saxon world. His insights into inflation, devaluation, and monetary stability would reappear in later discussions in the United States, especially in the controversies between Hamilton’s Federalists—who favored strong financial institutions—and positions more suspicious of monetary power, present in authors like John Adams.

1571

Tomás de Mercado: trade and credit

Read moreRead less
In his Suma de tratos y contratos, Mercado studies international commerce, banking, and credit in an emerging global economy. He defends the moral legitimacy of mercantile activity and describes the market as a complex system of voluntary exchanges. His analyses of commerce, risk, and currency circulation anticipate fundamental elements of modern political economy and the commercial world that both British classical economics and the financial institutions of the young American state would inherit.

1599

Juan de Mariana: De Rege et Regis Institutione

Read moreRead less
Mariana argues that power originally belongs to the people and is delegated to the ruler. He defends consent for taxation, the limitation of political power, and the legitimacy of resisting a tyrant, anticipating liberal constitutionalism. His theses circulated widely in Protestant Europe and were known by authors such as Grotius, Pufendorf, and especially John Locke, whose formulations on property, fiscal consent, and the right to rebellion present almost literal parallels with the work of the Spanish Jesuit. Through Locke, these ideas would pass to the Atlantic world: John Adams owned and actively sought Mariana’s work, Jefferson shared it with friends, and several Founding Fathers shared his books. Even from a broader Anglo-American perspective, it is difficult to explain the liberal tradition exclusively as a British product: if Adam Smith spent years in France in contact with the physiocrats—in an intellectual environment where Mariana was widely known after having taught at the Sorbonne—it is unlikely that he ignored his political-economic thought. It is no coincidence that the French republican allegory itself is named "Marianne" and appears represented in Eugène Delacroix's Liberty Leading the People, reflecting a European tradition of popular sovereignty prior to the Scottish Enlightenment.

1609–1610

The trial of Juan de Mariana: money, taxation and tyranny

Read moreRead less
After publishing De Monetae Mutatione, Mariana is accused of treason for stating that monetary manipulation equals a hidden tax and that the king cannot appropriate the property of his subjects without consent. He defends that natural law is superior to the power of the State and that taxation without representation constitutes a form of theft. His theses—inflation as a tax, popular sovereignty, and the right of resistance—anticipate formulations that would appear later in the motto of the American Revolution: "No taxation without representation".

1610–1614

Robert Bellarmine: De Laicis

Read moreRead less
Bellarmine, formed in the intellectual environment of the Second Scholasticism and in direct dialogue with the theologians and jurists of the Hispanic tradition, develops and systematizes principles already present in the Iberian universities on the social origin of political power. He formulates that authority comes from God but resides originally in the political community, which decides to whom to delegate it. He thus rejects the absolute divine right of kings and maintains that civil power exists for the common good and can change forms if it ceases to fulfill that end. These theses circulated in European debate through his critics—especially Robert Filmer—whose refutations brought the doctrine of popular sovereignty to the forefront for English readers. Thomas Jefferson owned and annotated Patriarcha, where Bellarmine's arguments are quoted extensively, and the controversy helped transfer to the Anglo-Saxon world the idea that power derives from the consent of the governed. In this way, principles present in the Virginia Declaration of Rights and the Declaration of Independence reproduce formulations developed by the cardinal two centuries earlier.

1613

Francisco Suárez: Defensio Fidei

Read moreRead less
Suárez, a central figure of the Second Scholasticism, systematizes the doctrine of the social origin of political power in Defensio Fidei (1613): authority proceeds from God, but resides first in the community and is only transmitted to the ruler by the consent of the people. With this, he rejects the absolute divine right of kings and grounds the legitimacy of limiting or deposing an unjust ruler. His work was read in England in the context of the controversies over the Stuart monarchy. These ideas would pass into English political thought and later appear systematized in Locke, conforming one of the intellectual bases of the British constitutional tradition.

TRANSMISSION TO PROTESTANT EUROPETransmission
1654

Marchamont Nedham: The Excellencie of a Free-State

Read moreRead less
In the republican England following the Civil War, Nedham defends that sovereignty resides in the people and that political power must be permanently limited by representative institutions. His work is part of the anti-absolutist parliamentary tradition that had previously incorporated arguments from the Second Scholasticism. Through this republican literature, principles formulated by authors like Suárez, Bellarmine, or Mariana arrive at Anglo-Saxon political thought: John Adams would cite Nedham when discussing the separation of powers and resistance against arbitrary power.

1680

Robert Filmer: Patriarcha

Read moreRead less
Filmer writes Patriarcha as a defense of the divine right of kings against the European anti-absolutist tradition. To refute it, he dedicates his first pages to directly attacking Robert Bellarmine and the Second Scholasticism, extensively quoting the thesis that civil authority resides originally in the community and is delegated by consent. The work was widely read in England and later in the American colonies—Thomas Jefferson owned and annotated a copy—so the controversy contributed to introducing into the Anglo-Saxon world precisely the ideas he sought to combat.

1688–1689

The Glorious Revolution and John Locke: Two Treatises of Government

Read moreRead less
In the context of the Glorious Revolution, Locke formulates the political theory that legitimizes English parliamentarianism. These approaches present notable parallels with the Hispanic scholastic tradition—especially with Juan de Mariana. Evidence of intellectual transmission exists: Locke knew and recommended works by Mariana, possessed his texts in his library, and shared with him theses on the origin of society, the nature of property, and the limitation of political power.

TOWARDS AMERICATowards America
1639

Fundamental Orders of Connecticut

Read moreRead less
Considered one of the first constitutional texts of the modern world, it establishes a government based on the consent of the political community and the institutional limitation of power. This approach reflects the English constitutional tradition after the anti-absolutist controversies of the 17th century, in which scholastic theses on popular sovereignty had already been incorporated.

18th–19th centuries

American reception of scholastic thought

Read moreRead less
The works of Juan de Mariana circulated widely in England and the American colonies. His defense of political consent, limited power, and inviolable property dialogued with Locke's thought and passed into colonial political culture. Thomas Jefferson discovered Mariana and even gifted copies of his work, and John Adams included at least two of his works in his library.

FOUNDATION OF THE UNITED STATESFoundation
1776

Declaration of Independence

Read moreRead less
The principle of natural rights granted by the Creator and the consent of the governed reflects the doctrine developed by Francisco de Vitoria and Francisco Suárez, where political power is understood as delegated authority. The idea that an unjust government loses legitimacy coincides with Juan de Mariana's formulation on the legitimacy of resisting the tyrant.

1776

Virginia Declaration of Rights

Read moreRead less
The right to alter an unjust government and popular sovereignty find direct precedents in Mariana and Suárez. The colonial critique of taxation without representation also reproduces the scholastic argument against taxes without consent developed in the Salamancan tradition.

1787

United States Constitution

Read moreRead less
The establishment of a limited government with separation of powers and popular sovereignty reflects the juridical tradition developed by Suárez and Bellarmine, where political authority is conceived as delegated power oriented to the common good.

1789

Bill of Rights

Read moreRead less
The guarantee of individual liberties and the protection of private property relate to the defense of natural rights formulated by Vitoria and the inviolability of property in Mariana. The limitation of state power follows the theoretical framework developed by the Second Scholasticism.

Biographies · A conversation between traditions

Two chronological sequences by year of birth: Hispanic authors and their Anglo-American interlocutors. Open each biography to explore connections, works and references. Each entry explains the nature of the reception, debate, refutation or affinity.

Hispanic tradition

Francisco de Vitoria

Francisco de Vitoria was born in Burgos around 1483 and died in Salamanca on August 12, 1546. He entered the Order of Preachers (Dominicans) and was intellectually trained at the University of Paris, the main European theological center of his time, where he studied Thomas Aquinas in depth. Upon his return to Spain he was appointed Professor of Theology at the University of Salamanca, from where he promoted an intellectual renewal that would mark European thought for centuries and would give rise to the so-called Second Scholasticism.

The historical context of his work was decisive: the discovery of America posed a radically new problem to Europe for the first time. What legitimacy did a Christian power have to dominate non-Christian peoples? The medieval tradition did not offer clear answers for a truly global reality. Vitoria turned this practical question into a universal philosophical problem.

His teachings are preserved in the Relectiones, academic lectures given between 1537 and 1540 and published posthumously, among which De Indis (1539) and De iure belli (1539) stand out. In them he rejects two dominant ideas of his time: the universal authority of the Pope over all humanity and the automatic right of conquest through religious or cultural superiority. No nation, he maintains, can legitimately appropriate the political dominion of another simply because it is pagan or less civilized.

His argument is based on a revolutionary premise for the 16th century: all human beings share the same rational nature and, therefore, possess natural political rights. The indigenous American peoples have legitimate sovereignty over their territories, their laws and their rulers. Religious conversion cannot be imposed by force, and war can only be justified under strict criteria of justice.

With this, Vitoria transformed moral theology into universal political theory. The political community is not born of power, but of human sociability. Power is legitimate only if it protects the common good and respects a prior moral order. Thus the notion of modern ius gentium arises: there is a law of nations prior to any empire.

This idea inaugurates contemporary international law. Relations between peoples are not based on religious or imperial hierarchies, but on common norms derived from natural reason: freedom of trade, the right of communication between peoples, protection of innocents in war and limits on the use of force. War ceases to be a normal instrument of political expansion and becomes an exceptional resource subject to legal conditions.

The philosophical scope is profound. Vitoria introduces the notion of rights prior to the State: political authority does not create human dignity, it recognizes it. Power is subordinated to justice. This principle, first applied to the relationship between empires and indigenous peoples, will end up influencing the modern idea of human rights and the conditional legitimacy of government.

In this way, Francisco de Vitoria establishes the remote foundation of constitutionalism: if there are rights prior to power, the government must be limited by higher norms. Politics stops being mere domination and becomes a legal order. His thought opens the way towards a universalist conception of the human community, where no authority can claim absolute legitimacy without reference to natural law.

Founder of modern international law; defended the natural rights of indigenous people and sovereignty based on reason.

Bartolomé de las Casas

Bartolomé de las Casas was born in Seville in 1484, the son of a merchant who had participated in Columbus’s second voyage. He came to America as a young man and received encomiendas, but his direct experience with the colonial system led him to a profound moral conversion. He entered the Dominican order and dedicated his life to the legal defense of indigenous people.

His activity was both intellectual and political: he participated in imperial debates, influenced legislation, and was a protagonist in the famous Valladolid controversy (1550–1551). He was not simply a humanitarian; He developed a complete legal theory.

In the Apologetics summary history and other writings he maintains that indigenous peoples possess full political reason. They have cities, laws and legitimate authority. Therefore, no war of conquest is just without real prior aggression.

Las Casas goes beyond Vitoria: he affirms that evangelization does not grant political dominance. Conversion must be free and civil power remains in the hands of the people.

His doctrine introduces universal legal equality as an operating principle. This is not just about spiritual dignity: it involves institutional consequences, including local self-government and limits on imperial authority.

He died in Madrid in 1566. His thoughts influenced Indian legislation and later European debates on human rights and colonization.

Proposed universal legal equality and argued that civil power belongs to the people, regardless of their religion.

Martín de Azpilcueta

Martín de Azpilcueta was born in Barásoain (Navarra) in 1492, the same year of the discovery of America, and died in Rome on June 21, 1586. A canon and theologian trained in Alcalá and Toulouse, he developed most of his academic career as a professor at the universities of Salamanca and Coimbra, becoming one of the most influential legal figures of the European Renaissance. He was known in his time as Doctor Navarrus, a name under which his works were widely circulated throughout Europe.

Although he wrote numerous treatises on canon and moral law—among them the influential Manual of Confessors and Penitents (1553)—his decisive contribution to the history of economic thought can be found in the Resolutory Commentary on Changes (1556). This short text, initially written to provide moral guidance to merchants and bankers, contains a revolutionary intuition: the value of money depends on its relative abundance or scarcity in society.

Azpilcueta empirically observed a new phenomenon in 16th century Castile: the massive arrival of American silver had not really enriched the population, but rather had raised prices across the board. That is, money had lost purchasing power. From this observation he concluded that the currency is not valid by decree of the sovereign or by its materiality, but by its relationship with the available goods and with social demand.

This was the first clear formulation of the quantity theory of money: when the quantity of currency increases, its value decreases.

The philosophical scope of this idea is enormous. Until then, currency was conceived mainly as a legal instrument of political power; Azpilcueta turns it into a social phenomenon. Money comes to be understood as an institution that emerges from human relationships, not as a sovereign creation capable of generating wealth by itself.

A moral consequence derives from this premise: if altering the quantity of money reduces its value, then monetary manipulation unfairly harms citizens. Inflation is equivalent to a non-consensual transfer of wealth. Therefore, authority cannot enrich itself through devaluations without violating distributive justice. Monetary policy is subject to the moral law.

Azpilcueta thus introduces an idea that centuries later will be central to modern political philosophy: power cannot indirectly appropriate private property through invisible technical mechanisms. Wealth is not created by decree; it can only arise from work, exchange and production. The State does not control the economic value, but must respect a prior order.

His thinking anticipates later debates about fiat money, inflation as a hidden tax, and constitutional limits on fiscal power. In the Anglo-Saxon world these issues would later appear linked to the protection of property and distrust of monetary manipulation by political authority.

In this way, Azpilcueta not only inaugurates modern monetary theory, but also introduces an ethical dimension to economics: monetary stability is a question of justice. The economic order, like the political one, cannot be based on the arbitrariness of power but on general rules respectful of human freedom. His reflection turns currency into a moral phenomenon rather than an administrative one, thus preparing one of the conceptual pillars of later economic thought.

First formulated the quantity theory of money, linking its value to scarcity and criticizing monetary manipulation.

Ambrosio de Morales

Humanist, historian and royal chronicler, Ambrosio de Morales was born in Córdoba in 1513 and died there on 21 September 1591. He investigated the past through documents, inscriptions and material remains. His work belongs to sixteenth-century Hispanic humanism and the renewal of historical methods.

His attention to institutions and historical experience found readers beyond Iberia. Marchamont Nedham invokes him alongside Juan de Mariana in The Excellencie of a Free-State (1656), when discussing the distribution of power. John Adams reproduces that passage in his Defence (1787–1788), preserving a Hispanic reference within Anglo-American constitutional debate.

Tomás de Mercado

Tomás de Mercado (c. 1525–1575) was a Dominican whose education and work spanned New Spain and Seville. He died in 1575 during the return voyage to New Spain, off Veracruz.

In Suma de tratos y contratos (1569; expanded edition 1571), he examined commerce, exchange, loans and justice in transactions. His moral theology considers just price, usury, fraud and contractual obligations; it does not simply equate economic justice with the absence of regulation.

Analysed contracts, money and Atlantic commerce within moral theology.

Juan de Mariana

Juan de Mariana was born in Talavera de la Reina (Crown of Castile) on April 2, 1536 and died in Toledo on February 17, 1624. He entered the Company of Jesus at a very young age and was trained in Alcalá de Henares and Rome. During his youth he taught theology at the Roman College and at the Sorbonne in Paris, a decisive experience because it put him in direct contact with the French religious wars, the problem of tyrannicide, and European debates on political legitimacy. Upon his definitive return to Spain he settled in Toledo, where he wrote most of his historical, economic and political work.

Although he was an extremely prolific author—his Historiae de rebus Hispaniae (1592) was for centuries the official history of Spain—his philosophical relevance is concentrated in three fields: theory of political power, right of resistance, and monetary criticism.

His most influential work, De Rege et Regis Institutione (1599), constitutes one of the most radical texts of European political philosophy before the Enlightenment. In it Mariana develops a complete theory of political legitimacy based on natural law. It states that power belongs neither to the king by nature nor by direct divine right, but originally to the political community, which delegates it to the ruler for the common good. The monarch is therefore a fiduciary magistrate, not an owner of the State.

From this premise he derives his most famous thesis: if the ruler violates natural law—oppresses freedom, confiscates property, or rules arbitrarily—he becomes a tyrant and can be deposed. In certain extreme circumstances, it even justifies tyrannicide. This is not a defense of indiscriminate political violence, but rather a logical consequence: if authority derives from the people, it loses legitimacy when it destroys the moral order it was supposed to protect.

Mariana also formulates a surprisingly modern tax theory: taxes require consent. Taxation without social approval is morally equivalent to expropriation. This idea directly anticipates the later constitutional principle of political representation.

Even more novel was his financial contribution. In De Monetae Mutatione (1609) he criticized the Crown’s manipulation of currency—the reduction of the metallic content of coins—as a form of covert theft. He argued that the inflation generated by the authority is an illegitimate tax because it reduces purchasing power without the consent of citizens. Here appears for the first time a moral formulation of the modern monetary problem: political power cannot indirectly appropriate private property through devaluation.

These theses cost him a legal process for lese majeste in 1609–1610. He was arrested, interrogated by the Inquisition and his work was banned and burned in Paris in 1610 following the assassination of Henry IV, which some attributed to the spread of his ideas about tyranny. Although he was not ultimately convicted, the episode reveals the extent to which his theories were perceived as politically explosive in absolutist Europe.

The historical importance of Mariana lies in the fact that it connects three planes that until then had remained partially separated: moral theology, public law and economics. For him, political freedom does not depend only on the form of government, but also on respect for property, a healthy currency and fiscal consent. The State is thus subordinated to a prior moral order.

His ideas circulated widely in England during the 17th century, amidst the polemics against absolutism, and many of his arguments later reappeared in Locke: popular sovereignty, the right of resistance, the protective function of government, and the centrality of property. Indirectly, these principles passed into American constitutionalism. It is no coincidence that John Adams owned a copy of De Rege and that Jefferson knew his work.

Mariana thus represents one of the culminating points of the Second Scholasticism: a thought that, starting from Thomism, manages to formulate a fully modern theory of limited power. In his philosophy, the State ceases to be an almost natural reality and becomes a morally conditioned institution. His conclusion can be summarized in a simple but revolutionary idea for its time: political power exists to protect human freedom and loses legitimacy when it stops doing so.

Affirmed that power resides in the community; criticized inflation as theft and justified the deposition of the tyrant.

Roberto Belarmino

Roberto Francisco Rómulo Belarmino was born in Montepulciano (Grand Duchy of Tuscany) on October 4, 1542 and died in Rome on September 17, 1621. He entered the Society of Jesus at a very young age and was trained in Rome, Padua and Leuven, soon becoming one of the great theologians of the Counter-Reformation. He was a professor at the Roman College, cardinal since 1599 and doctrinal advisor to the papacy in an era marked by the European religious wars, the crisis of authority after the Protestant Reformation and the rise of absolute monarchies.

Although his historical fame is often linked to the controversy with Protestantism—his monumental Disputationes de Controversiis Christianae Fidei (1586–1593) was the most influential theological treatise of modern Catholicism—his philosophical-political importance is equally profound. In works such as De Laicis (1610), De potestate summi pontificis in rebus temporalibus (1610), and in several previous political texts integrated into the Controversies, Bellarmine formulated a theory of civil power that transformed the European debate on sovereignty.

Its central thesis is based on a key distinction: political power comes from God in terms of its moral origin—because human sociability is part of nature—but is not granted directly to any specific ruler. It resides first in the political community, which decides the form of government and delegates authority. The king, therefore, does not rule by personal divine right, but through the mediation of the people.

This position frontally attacked the doctrine of the divine right of kings defended by English and French absolutist theorists. Against the idea that the monarch is the immediate vicar of God, Bellarmine maintains that the ruler is a derived authority: the political community is the immediate subject of power and the prince its administrator.

From this premise it introduces a decisive consequence: if authority comes from the consent of the community, it can be modified when it no longer fulfills its purpose—the common good. He does not develop the direct defense of tyrannicide as Mariana will do, but he establishes the legal basis of later constitutionalism: political authority is conditional.

His thinking had an enormous impact precisely among his adversaries. The Anglican Robert Filmer wrote Patriarcha (published in 1680) to refute him, and in doing so spread his ideas in England. The historical paradox is that, by attacking Bellarmine, he introduced his theory of popular sovereignty into the English political debate that would lead to the Glorious Revolution and Locke.

Belarmino also contributed a structural reflection on the forms of government. He considered that no pure system—monarchy, aristocracy, or democracy—was perfect, and defended a mixed constitution capable of balancing stability and freedom. This idea anticipates the model of combined government that will characterize modern constitutionalism and that will later appear in British and American political thought.

His influence was particularly important in the Iberian scholastic tradition: Suárez systematized his theory, and Mariana radicalized its consequences. In this way, Bellarmine occupies a decisive intermediate position: he translates medieval Thomism into modern political language and provides the conceptual basis that will allow us to think of power as representation and not as property.

Ultimately, his philosophical contribution consists of having definitively separated political legitimacy and absolutism. For Bellarmine, authority is not a sacred force inherent to the ruler, but rather a moral function delegated by the community to preserve justice. With this he contributed to the intellectual transition that would lead from medieval political theology to contemporary constitutionalism: power is legitimate only as long as it remains ordered to the common good and sustained by the consent of those who obey it.

Held that civil authority is mediate and derived from popular consent, influencing constitutionalism.

Francisco Suárez

Francisco Suárez was born in Granada on January 5, 1548 and died in Lisbon on September 25, 1617. A Jesuit, professor in Salamanca, Rome, Alcalá, Coimbra and Évora, he was one of the greatest systematic philosophers of the Modern Age and probably the last great scholastic metaphysician with direct influence on European politics. His work encompasses metaphysics, moral theology, and legal philosophy, but his political impact was especially concentrated in Defensio Fidei Catholicae adversus Anglicanae sectae errors (1613).

The Defensio Fidei was written in a very specific context: the English political-religious crisis after the Anglican Reformation. King James I of England had imposed the Oath of Allegiance (1606), which required the denial of any supratemporal authority over the monarch and consolidated a doctrine of absolute divine right of the king. Suárez’s work sought to refute that position, but his response ended up having much broader consequences than mere confessional controversy.

Suárez precisely formulated a revolutionary thesis: political power comes from God as the ultimate foundation of the moral order, but it is not delivered directly to the king, but first to the political community, which delegates it to the ruler through consent. The king is not the owner of power; He is your administrator. Therefore, civil authority is essentially fiduciary.

This doctrine implied three decisive consequences:

The origin of power is social, not personal.

The ruler is limited by the common good and natural law.

A community can resist the tyrant if he destroys the legal order.

James I immediately understood the political significance of the work. In 1614 he ordered the public burning of the Defensio Fideien London and Oxford. The text was considered not only theologically dangerous but also constitutionally subversive: it denied the intellectual basis of English absolutism at a time of growing tensions between Crown and Parliament.

Paradoxically, the English condemnation favored its dissemination. European universities—including those in the Protestant sphere—debated the Suarezian thesis, and its arguments indirectly passed into the British political vocabulary. In the following decades, during the controversies of the 17th century (English Civil War, Commonwealth, and Glorious Revolution), the central question would no longer be whether power comes from God—that was accepted—but rather who it immediately belongs to: the king or the people.

In that sense, Suárez did not influence England as a massively read author, but as an inevitable political problem. The defenders of absolutism had to refute him; The constitutionalists ended up assuming its conceptual structure: mediate popular sovereignty, limited government and delegated power. The Anglo-Saxon political philosophy of consent—which will culminate in Locke—develops within that previously defined polemical framework.

Thus, Suárez’s contribution was not simply theological. By transferring sovereignty from the person of the monarch to the political community, he provided the conceptual architecture on which modern theories of constitutionalism would be built: power as a revocable trust and subordinate to a higher legal order.

Systematized the theory of delegated power: sovereignty resides in the people and the ruler is a fiduciary administrator.

Anglo-American tradition

Robert Filmer

Refutation

English royalist Robert Filmer made the rejection of natural liberty central to his defence of kingship. Patriarcha, published posthumously in 1680, derives political authority from Adam’s paternal power and challenges the claim that originally free people must consent to government.

In chapter I, Filmer explicitly discusses Bellarmine and Suárez on authority originally belonging to the community. His opponents thus become interlocutors whose arguments he preserves while attacking them. Locke and Sidney subsequently respond to Filmer, extending this controversy into a different political and religious setting.

Works and references

Robert Filmer, Patriarcha; or, The Natural Power of Kings (1680), I, §§1–2, 5. John Locke, Two Treatises of Government, I, §§6–7.

Textual reception

An English publicist of the Civil Wars and Commonwealth, Nedham examined how a free state could prevent its rulers from turning public office into permanent domination. The Excellencie of a Free-State (1656) discusses the distinction between making laws and executing them.

Nedham invokes Ambrosio de Morales and explicitly refers to Juan de Mariana when describing historical limits on Spanish royal power. John Adams later reproduces this passage in his discussion of Nedham. The sequence Morales and Mariana → Nedham → Adams provides a concrete textual route from Hispanic historical writing through English republicanism to American constitutional debate.

Works and references

Marchamont Nedham, The Excellencie of a Free-State (1656), pp. 218–220; The Founders’ Constitution, I, ch. 10, document 2. John Adams, Works, VI, p. 175.

Algernon Sidney

Debate and reception

English republican Algernon Sidney defended political authority as an institution justified by the good of the governed. His Discourses Concerning Government, published posthumously in 1698, offers an extensive response to Robert Filmer’s patriarchal theory.

In II, §5, Sidney explicitly mentions Suárez and Bellarmine before developing his own account of free people forming a society and establishing common laws. This is a textual encounter across different confessional and political traditions. Jefferson’s letter to Henry Lee of 8 May 1825 names Sidney among the authorities associated with the intellectual horizon of the Declaration.

Works and references

Algernon Sidney, Discourses Concerning Government (1698), II, §5; Thomas G. West (ed.), Liberty Fund (1996). Thomas Jefferson → Henry Lee, 8 May 1825.

George Fox

Affinity · freedom of conscience

English preacher George Fox helped found the Quaker movement. His journeys, letters and communities formed an Atlantic network centred on inward religious experience and consistency between faith and conduct. His 1656 letter from Launceston urges ministers to address all nations and recognise the presence of God in each person.

The comparison with Bartolomé de las Casas concerns persuasion, conscience and human dignity. Las Casas’s account of persuasive evangelisation and Fox’s appeal to conscience offer different Christian responses to coercion in matters of faith. The connection presented here is an affinity of questions and commitments.

Works and references

George Fox, Launceston (1656), Quaker Faith & Practice, §19.32; Journal (1694). Bartolomé de las Casas, De unico vocationis modo.

John Locke

Controversy mediated by Filmer

English philosopher John Locke connected questions of knowledge, toleration and legitimate government with the conflicts of seventeenth-century England. His Two Treatises of Government appeared in 1689 with a 1690 imprint: the first attacks patriarchalism; the second develops an account of civil government.

In the First Treatise, §§6–7, Locke examines Filmer’s treatment of Bellarmine and challenges its supposed proof of absolute paternal authority. The Second Treatise develops consent, rights and limited government within Locke’s own philosophy. Jefferson names Locke among his authorities in the letter to Henry Lee of 1825.

Works and references

John Locke, Two Treatises of Government (1689–1690), I, §§6–7; II, §§95–99. Thomas Jefferson → Henry Lee, 8 May 1825.

William Penn

Affinity · religious liberty

Quaker thinker and founder of Pennsylvania, William Penn brought the problem of freedom of conscience into the organisation of an American political community. Religious persecution in England informed his defence of toleration and guarantees against confessional coercion.

The Great Case of Liberty of Conscience (1670), Pennsylvania’s Frame of Government (1682) and the Charter of Privileges (1701) mark this intellectual and institutional trajectory. Comparison with Las Casas centres on freely embraced faith and personal dignity: distinct formulations in Hispanic discussions of evangelisation and Quaker constitutional arrangements.

Works and references

William Penn, The Great Case of Liberty of Conscience (1670); Frame of Government of Pennsylvania (1682); Charter of Privileges (1701). Quakers in the World, “Freedom of Conscience” (Penn, 1669).

Adam Smith

Affinity · exchange and justice

Scottish moral philosopher Adam Smith studied sociability, moral judgement and commercial institutions. The Theory of Moral Sentiments (1759) and The Wealth of Nations (1776) place justice and exchange within a broader account of social life.

Comparison with Tomás de Mercado concerns price formation, legitimate exchange and the obligations limiting self-interest. Mercado approaches these through the moral theology of contracts; Smith through Scottish Enlightenment moral philosophy and political economy. Smith’s emphasis on justice as indispensable to society supplies a shared question through which their different answers can be explored.

Works and references

Adam Smith, The Theory of Moral Sentiments (1759), II.ii.3; The Wealth of Nations (1776), I, IV–VII. Tomás de Mercado, Suma de tratos y contratos (1571).

John Adams

Reception through Nedham

Jurist, diplomat and second president of the United States, John Adams compared historical constitutions to examine the distribution and balance of power in A Defence of the Constitutions of Government of the United States of America (1787–1788).

In his treatment of Nedham, Adams reproduces the passage invoking Ambrosio de Morales and Juan de Mariana (Works, VI, p. 175). A distinct material trace complements this textual reception: the Boston Public Library’s John Adams collection holds a 1611 edition of Mariana’s De rege et regis institutione. Together they illuminate the book’s transatlantic circulation.

Works and references

John Adams, A Defence of the Constitutions of Government of the United States of America (1787–1788); Charles Francis Adams (ed.), The Works of John Adams, VI (1851), p. 175. Juan de Mariana, De rege et regis institutione (1611), John Adams Library, Boston Public Library.

James Wilson

Affinity · consent and natural law

Born in Scotland and established in America, jurist James Wilson signed the Declaration of Independence and participated in framing the federal Constitution. His Lectures on Law examine legal obligation and the authority of the people.

Wilson rejects the assumption that a ruler’s superiority alone provides a title to command. Political legitimacy requires freedom and consent. Reading him alongside Suárez brings a shared question into view: how can free persons constitute binding political authority? Each answers within his own framework of natural law; Wilson’s discussion belongs to American constitutional institution-building.

Works and references

James Wilson, Lectures on Law, I, II, “Of the General Principles of Law and Obligation”; Kermit L. Hall & Mark David Hall (eds.), Collected Works of James Wilson, Liberty Fund (2007), I. Francisco Suárez, De legibus (1612), III.

Thomas Jefferson

Indirect reception

The principal drafter of the Declaration and third president of the United States, Thomas Jefferson explained its intellectual horizon in his letter to Henry Lee of 8 May 1825. The Declaration, he wrote, expressed shared convictions in a form appropriate to the occasion.

Jefferson lists Aristotle, Cicero, Locke and Sidney among authorities of public right. The letter belongs to the Thomas Jefferson Papers at the Library of Congress and is edited in Founders Online. Locke and Sidney had themselves engaged with Filmer’s patriarchalism, a controversy involving Suárez and Bellarmine. This sequence permits the study of indirect reception across European and American debates.

Works and references

Thomas Jefferson → Henry Lee, Monticello, 8 May 1825, Thomas Jefferson Papers, Library of Congress; Founders Online. Algernon Sidney, Discourses Concerning Government, II, §5.

James Brown Scott

Historiography

American jurist and historian James Brown Scott helped recover Spanish theologians and jurists for twentieth-century debates on international law. The Spanish Origin of International Law (1934) places Francisco de Vitoria at the centre of a genealogy of relations among political communities, war and the rights of peoples.

His reading of De Indis and De iure belli addresses conquest, legitimate titles and limits on warfare. This is an explicit historiographical reception: Scott reconstructs a tradition and connects sixteenth-century Salamanca with modern discussions of the legal foundations of international relations.

Works and references

James Brown Scott, The Spanish Origin of International Law: Francisco de Vitoria and His Law of Nations, Oxford, Clarendon Press (1934). Francisco de Vitoria, De Indis; De iure belli (1539).

Joseph Schumpeter

History of economic analysis

Economist Joseph Schumpeter’s posthumous History of Economic Analysis (1954), edited by Elizabeth Boody Schumpeter, extends the history of the discipline beyond the conventional starting point of Adam Smith.

Its treatment of scholastic doctors and natural-law philosophers identifies analysis of prices, money, interest and contracts within moral theology. The connection with Mercado and other scholastics is historiographical: religious and legal texts also contain economic explanations. Their recovery broadens the canon and the boundaries between economics, law and moral philosophy.

Works and references

Joseph A. Schumpeter, History of Economic Analysis, Elizabeth Boody Schumpeter (ed.), 1954, II, ch. 2, “The Scholastic Doctors and the Philosophers of Natural Law”.

Legal study and reception

German jurist Heinrich Rommen developed part of his academic career in the Anglo-American world, ultimately teaching at Georgetown. Die ewige Wiederkehr des Naturrechts (1936), translated as The Natural Law, examines the history and philosophical foundations of natural law.

Rommen distinguishes classical and scholastic natural law from modern natural-rights doctrines. His engagement with Suárez concerns authority and the relationship between law and moral order. This reception carries scholastic questions into twentieth-century jurisprudence, distinguishing the legality of a decision from its justice.

Works and references

Heinrich A. Rommen, Die ewige Wiederkehr des Naturrechts (1936); The Natural Law: A Study in Legal and Social History and Philosophy, Thomas R. Hanley (1947), Liberty Fund (1998).

Friedrich A. Hayek

Modern recovery

Austrian-born economist Friedrich A. Hayek, active in British and American academic life, studied social coordination, knowledge and the limits of planning. His interest in intellectual history also encompassed Spanish scholastic economics.

In a letter to Joaquín Reig dated 7 January 1979, Hayek proposed a Salamanca meeting on the Spanish origins of economic liberalism and recommended Marjorie Grice-Hutchinson and Murray Rothbard. This explicit recognition connects modern scholarship with Azpilcueta and the Salamanca tradition, especially their discussions of money and markets.

Works and references

Friedrich A. Hayek → Joaquín Reig, Freiburg, 7 January 1979. Marjorie Grice-Hutchinson, The School of Salamanca (1952).

Eric Voegelin

Affinity · order and limits on power

A political philosopher educated in central Europe who pursued a career in the United States, Eric Voegelin studied the religious and philosophical experiences through which societies understand their order. The New Science of Politics (1952) and Order and History investigate its symbols and foundations.

Comparison with Suárez concerns community, authority and a moral horizon that political power cannot create at will. Voegelin approaches these questions through experience and the history of consciousness. The affinity opens a conversation about the person, truth and the good across distinct philosophical languages.

Works and references

Eric Voegelin, The New Science of Politics: An Introduction, University of Chicago Press (1952); Order and History (1956–1987). Eric Voegelin Institute, Louisiana State University.

John Courtney Murray

Later theological debate

American Jesuit theologian John Courtney Murray addressed religious liberty, civil authority and Church–State relations. In “Governmental Repression of Heresy” (1948), he explicitly examines Bellarmine’s theory of indirect power alongside John of Paris.

Murray investigates the political consequences of these theories and the historical understanding of governmental authority over religious dissent. This documented theological debate shows an early modern controversy being reconsidered in the twentieth century through questions of liberty, jurisdiction and religious pluralism.

Works and references

John Courtney Murray, “Governmental Repression of Heresy”, Proceedings of the Catholic Theological Society of America, 3 (1948), pp. 26–98. John Courtney Murray Archive, Georgetown University Library, “Bellarmine’s Theory of the Indirect Power”.

Marjorie Grice-Hutchinson

Historiography

British historian Marjorie Grice-Hutchinson helped recover Spanish writings on money, prices and exchange, combining historical research with translations that opened this corpus to English-language readers.

The School of Salamanca: Readings in Spanish Monetary Theory, 1544–1605 (1952) includes materials for understanding Azpilcueta’s relationship between monetary abundance and purchasing power. Her contribution supplies texts and a reading itinerary for subsequent economic historians. Hayek explicitly recommended her work in his 1979 letter to Joaquín Reig.

Works and references

Marjorie Grice-Hutchinson, The School of Salamanca: Readings in Spanish Monetary Theory, 1544–1605, Oxford, Clarendon Press (1952). Martín de Azpilcueta, Comentario resolutorio de cambios (1556). Hayek → Joaquín Reig, 7 January 1979.

Murray Rothbard

Later interpretation

American economist Murray Rothbard incorporated Spanish scholastics into his reconstruction of economic thought before Adam Smith, emphasising property, exchange, money and limits on political power.

In Economic Thought Before Adam Smith (1995), he examines Mariana’s criticism of monetary debasement alongside consent and rulers’ appropriation of resources. This is a later reception from Austrian economics and libertarian thought. Hayek recommended Rothbard’s “New Light on the Prehistory of the Austrian School” in 1979.

Works and references

Murray N. Rothbard, Economic Thought Before Adam Smith, I, Edward Elgar (1995), “The Learned Extremist: Juan de Mariana”; “New Light on the Prehistory of the Austrian School”, Edwin G. Dolan (ed.), The Foundations of Modern Austrian Economics (1976).

Founding Fathers

Key figures of the American Revolution whose intellectual training and personal library reveal a significant connection with the scholastic tradition.

John Adams

Adams read and cited Juan de Mariana, incorporating him into his constitutional reflection alongside the English republican tradition. Through these readings, Adams assumed the superiority of natural law over arbitrary power, incorporating into American thought the idea of a fiduciary power, limited and subordinated to the common good, typical of Iberian scholasticism.

Thomas Jefferson

Jefferson showed a sustained interest in Hispanic culture: he acquired and read Don Quixote. During his diplomatic stay in Europe, he expanded his political library—including works by Juan de Mariana—and also took interest in Juan de Palafox y Mendoza. In Jefferson's library, there is a look toward Spain not only literary but also political, connecting natural law, human dignity, and the limitation of power with American republicanism.

James Madison

In The Federalist Papers, Madison develops the idea that sovereignty resides in the people but must be exercised through institutions that channel and limit political power. His defense of representative government reproduces—although without explicit citation—the scholastic tradition of a prudential mixed order. The Constitution appears as the stable institutional form of popular sovereignty, an indirect heir to Iberian political theory.

Alexander Hamilton

In the Report on Public Credit (1790) and the Report on a National Bank (1790), Hamilton links monetary stability, public trust, and political liberty. This concern connects with Juan de Mariana's critique in De Monetae Mutatione (1609), where currency manipulation is described as a hidden tax contrary to political consent. The economic architecture of the young republic incorporated debates originated two centuries earlier in Iberian moral theory.

Reception and Rediscovery

Orestes Brownson

(1803–1876)

The American Catholic political thinker defended that the Constitution is not an artificial contract but the juridical form of a prior political community. In The American Republic (1865) he maintains that sovereignty belongs to the people as a moral community and not to isolated individuals, a formulation extraordinarily close to Francisco Suárez.

John Courtney Murray

1960

In We Hold These Truths (1960), Murray interprets the First Amendment in light of the natural law tradition and recognizes the heritage of Suárez and Bellarmine in limited popular sovereignty.

Heinrich A. Rommen

1967

In The Natural Law (1947), Rommen presents the School of Salamanca as the origin of modern constitutionalism. His work becomes a manual in American law schools.

Carlos Stoetzer

1986

In The Scholastic Roots of the American Constitution (1986), Stoetzer systematically documents the influence of Vitoria, Suárez, and Mariana on the intellectual formation of American constitutionalism.

Project Axes

This project is organized around several operational and research axes:
01

Comparative studies between Hispanic American and United States emancipations.

02

Studies on the influence of the Hispanic tradition on the Founding Fathers of the United States.

03

Publications on the influence of the Hispanic tradition on the Anglo-American political tradition.

04

In-person and virtual events on the previous points.

"FOR SPAIN AND FOR THE KING" - AUGUSTO FERRER-DALMAU

The painting portrays a battle scene during the American Revolutionary War, highlighting Spanish participation.

Vision and Foundations

Project 1776 seeks to dust off the Hispanic tradition, unknown or forgotten by many, update it, and place it at the service of our societies and the West, as a complementary and necessary vision to the Anglo-American one.

"SISTER FLAGS" - AUGUSTO FERRER-DALMAU

This painting shows two majestic ships, one Spanish and one American, sailing together.

Bibliographic References

Gómez Rivas, L. (2026). ‘Orígenes escolásticos de la libertad individual en los EE. UU. en el aniversario de la Declaración de Independencia (1776-2026)’. Instituto Fe y Libertad

Graf, E.-C. (2019). ‘Escolásticos: Francisco Suárez, Juan de Mariana y las revoluciones en América. Bicentenario de la independencia 1810-30’. Credencial Historia, Bogotá, pp. 42-51

Gómez Rivas, L. (2017). ‘¿Conoció George Mason a los escolásticos españoles?’. Instituto Juan de Mariana

Gómez Rivas, L. (2021). ‘Escolástica e independencia: Las bibliotecas jesuitas al tiempo de la emancipación’.

Rager, J.C. (1925). ‘The Blessed Cardinal Bellarmine’s Defense of Popular Government in the Sixteenth Century’. The Catholic Historical Review, Vol. 10, No. 4

Stoetzer, C. (1981). ‘Las raíces escolásticas de la Revolución Americana’. Ponencia en las XV Jornadas de la Asociación Argentina de Estudios Americanos

Stoetzer, C. (1986). ‘The Scholastic Roots of the American Constitution’. Washington D.C.

Termes, R. (2000). ‘Francisco Suárez y The Fundamental Orders de Connecticut’. Cuadernos de Ciencias Económicas y Empresariales, 37 pp. 161-168

Termes, R. (2005). ‘La tradición hispana de libertad’. Conferencia en el Instituto Acton, Orlando

PARTICIPATE IN THE PROJECT

If you are a researcher, academic or wish to support this line of research for the 250th anniversary of the United States, contact us.

Become a Friend of Escuela Hispánica